COST:
Generally superchargers and turbochargers are approximately the
same cost pending on engine size and availability.
LAG:
More lag is generated on the turbo units because the impeller must
spool up before it can turn the compressor. On supercharged units
there is no lag because it is connected directly to the crank.
EFFICIENCY:
The turbocharger prevails as more efficient using exhaust gasses
that would otherwise be lost out the exhaust compared to a Supercharger
which draws power from the crank. Although turbochargers are not
free of inefficiency they do create additional exhaust backpressure
and exhaust flow interruption.
HEAT:
Because the turbocharger is mounted to the exhaust manifold it generates
excess heat creating a less dense air/fuel mixture. An intercooler
can correct this by cooling the air charge prior to entering the
engine. Superchargers generally don't create enough heat under 10
psi to require an intercooler although some roots-type superchargers
benefit from one.
SURGE:
There is a large surge on turbochargers because they must spool
up before delivering boost to the engine. The surge is caused when
the waste gate opens which is usually hard on the vehicles drivetrain.
Superchargers have no surge.
BACK
PRESSURE: Turbochargers cause substantial back pressure because
the turbine is placed directly in the exhaust flow oppose to generating
power from the crank.
NOISE:
Typically superchargers make more noise compare to turbochargers
without exhaust and intake modifications..
RELIABILITY:
Supercharges are generally the more reliable of the two. Due to
turbochargers high rpm and extreme heat the causeof internal damage
and premature bearing failure is common. (Let your turbo cool down
before you turn off your car!)
INSTALLATION:
Superchargers are usually easier to install because there are less
components and control devices needed. You will also have to do
manifold and exhaust modifications.
MAXIMUM
PERFORMANCE: Turbochargers prevail here. With speeds as high as
150 000 rpm, boost levels near 30 psi and new light weight designs.
They are capable of producing more power then superchargers.
|